{
  "reviewed": "2026-11-15",
  "scope": "Two one-way radio intervals, not a full flight reconstruction or calibrated orbit validation.",
  "cases": [
    {
      "date": "2026-04-08",
      "n": 2587,
      "start": "2026-04-08T00:12:36.500006Z",
      "end": "2026-04-08T01:02:35.500006Z",
      "station_assumption": {
        "latitude_deg": 52.812,
        "longitude_deg": 6.396,
        "ellipsoid_height_km": 0.025,
        "status": "Approximate site point, not a measured receiver phase centre"
      },
      "model": "RevF -24 with DE430, ITRF93 station, converged reception light time CN, geometric first-order one-way frequency f0*(1-range_rate/c); no relativistic frequency-transfer or propagation correction",
      "carrier_Hz": 2216500000.0,
      "observed_change_Hz": -254.5,
      "predicted_change_Hz": -252.6564826965332,
      "raw_median_offset_Hz": -2250.8076119422913,
      "constant_offset_removed_rms_Hz": 0.8408898700132593,
      "constant_offset_removed_p95_abs_Hz": 1.9879294872283935,
      "heldout": {
        "training_n": 1293,
        "training_median_offset_Hz": -2250.703935146332,
        "test_n": 1294,
        "test_mean_Hz": -0.20277763702769921,
        "test_rms_Hz": 0.7185741587588426,
        "test_p95_abs_Hz": 1.1860955953598016
      },
      "range_km": [
        367907.09610100277,
        365561.6685706904
      ],
      "range_rate_km_s": [
        -0.7985624635072391,
        -0.7643894393936143
      ],
      "sensitivity": [
        {
          "assumption": "+1km ECEF axis 0",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.36540746688842773
        },
        {
          "assumption": "+1km ECEF axis 1",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.37193918228149414
        },
        {
          "assumption": "+1km ECEF axis 2",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.003352642059326172
        },
        {
          "assumption": "-1 second timestamp",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.09260702133178711
        },
        {
          "assumption": "+1 second timestamp",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.09261226654052734
        },
        {
          "assumption": "No light time (deliberately incomplete)",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.5475878715515137
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-04-09",
      "n": 1644,
      "start": "2026-04-09T00:39:13.500006Z",
      "end": "2026-04-09T01:24:42.500006Z",
      "station_assumption": {
        "latitude_deg": 52.812,
        "longitude_deg": 6.396,
        "ellipsoid_height_km": 0.025,
        "status": "Approximate site point, not a measured receiver phase centre"
      },
      "model": "RevF -24 with DE430, ITRF93 station, converged reception light time CN, geometric first-order one-way frequency f0*(1-range_rate/c); no relativistic frequency-transfer or propagation correction",
      "carrier_Hz": 2216500000.0,
      "observed_change_Hz": -204.5,
      "predicted_change_Hz": -208.29629945755005,
      "raw_median_offset_Hz": -2195.032699108124,
      "constant_offset_removed_rms_Hz": 0.8386408085087242,
      "constant_offset_removed_p95_abs_Hz": 1.7107991456985474,
      "heldout": {
        "training_n": 822,
        "training_median_offset_Hz": -2195.5158066749573,
        "test_n": 822,
        "test_mean_Hz": 0.9972660118065901,
        "test_rms_Hz": 1.0493607976053083,
        "test_p95_abs_Hz": 1.4997472524642943
      },
      "range_km": [
        300586.46593456593,
        297693.0774411584
      ],
      "range_rate_km_s": [
        -1.073901182610176,
        -1.0457280901130497
      ],
      "sensitivity": [
        {
          "assumption": "+1km ECEF axis 0",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.3336448669433594
        },
        {
          "assumption": "+1km ECEF axis 1",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.3819007873535156
        },
        {
          "assumption": "+1km ECEF axis 2",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.004454135894775391
        },
        {
          "assumption": "-1 second timestamp",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.08283710479736328
        },
        {
          "assumption": "+1 second timestamp",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.08284139633178711
        },
        {
          "assumption": "No light time (deliberately incomplete)",
          "max_frequency_change_Hz": 0.6970558166503906
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "coverage": [
    {
      "filename": "art002_rec_260402_260410_jsc_bet_revf.bsp",
      "intervals": [
        {
          "start_UTC": "2026-04-02T01:58:21.397Z",
          "end_UTC": "2026-04-02T22:49:21.397Z",
          "duration_seconds": 75060.00000059605
        },
        {
          "start_UTC": "2026-04-02T22:49:59.741Z",
          "end_UTC": "2026-04-03T00:02:39.801Z",
          "duration_seconds": 4360.060000061989
        },
        {
          "start_UTC": "2026-04-03T00:02:48.802Z",
          "end_UTC": "2026-04-07T00:54:48.802Z",
          "duration_seconds": 348719.99999821186
        },
        {
          "start_UTC": "2026-04-07T00:55:00.000Z",
          "end_UTC": "2026-04-10T23:29:00.000Z",
          "duration_seconds": 340439.99999058247
        },
        {
          "start_UTC": "2026-04-10T23:29:59.780Z",
          "end_UTC": "2026-04-10T23:33:34.736Z",
          "duration_seconds": 214.95600008964539
        },
        {
          "start_UTC": "2026-04-10T23:33:44.736Z",
          "end_UTC": "2026-04-10T23:53:24.643Z",
          "duration_seconds": 1179.9069999456406
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "filename": "art002_rec_260402_260410_jsc_bet_revf_gapfill.bsp",
      "intervals": [
        {
          "start_UTC": "2026-04-02T22:49:21.397Z",
          "end_UTC": "2026-04-02T22:49:59.741Z",
          "duration_seconds": 38.3439998626709
        },
        {
          "start_UTC": "2026-04-03T00:02:39.801Z",
          "end_UTC": "2026-04-03T00:02:48.802Z",
          "duration_seconds": 9.001000046730042
        },
        {
          "start_UTC": "2026-04-07T00:54:48.802Z",
          "end_UTC": "2026-04-07T00:55:00.000Z",
          "duration_seconds": 11.197999954223633
        },
        {
          "start_UTC": "2026-04-10T23:29:00.000Z",
          "end_UTC": "2026-04-10T23:29:59.780Z",
          "duration_seconds": 59.77999997138977
        },
        {
          "start_UTC": "2026-04-10T23:33:34.736Z",
          "end_UTC": "2026-04-10T23:33:44.736Z",
          "duration_seconds": 10.0
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "covariance_epoch_records": 13186,
  "source_receipts": [
    {
      "filename": "earth_000101_261115_260819.bpc",
      "bytes": 5117952,
      "sha256": "326609835fc35b62bbe54157a472654b8267635af0719b7ce70150b42eae5f28",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/spice_kernels/pck/earth_000101_261115_260819.bpc"
    },
    {
      "filename": "earthstns_itrf93_260814.bsp",
      "bytes": 26624,
      "sha256": "007eb0aad5dd022c6d61bdbfb2395680bd1eb31c49a8637d0b0a1cfbea737c6b",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/spice_kernels/spk/earthstns_itrf93_260814.bsp"
    },
    {
      "filename": "earth_assoc_itrf93.tf",
      "bytes": 7522,
      "sha256": "aab7bbc19b8a69bad11988ee1b4812a3963812a03a029c2776863e680719b336",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/spice_kernels/fk/earth_assoc_itrf93.tf"
    },
    {
      "filename": "naif0012.tls",
      "bytes": 5257,
      "sha256": "678e32bdb5a744117a467cd9601cd6b373f0e9bc9bbde1371d5eee39600a039b",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/spice_kernels/lsk/naif0012.tls"
    },
    {
      "filename": "de430.bsp",
      "bytes": 119741440,
      "sha256": "6e1b277c5f07135a84950604b83e56b736be696a7f3560bcddb1d4aeb944fca1",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/spice_kernels/spk/de430.bsp"
    },
    {
      "filename": "art002_v0.tf",
      "bytes": 57135,
      "sha256": "88756b0d2a2aa71be2dadde3a7f6d8a54a78931f647516c26684494efcddbe02",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/spice_kernels/fk/art002_v0.tf"
    },
    {
      "filename": "pck00011.tpc",
      "bytes": 131226,
      "sha256": "3dff7b1dbeceaa01f25467767d3fa25816051c85d162d1edf04acb310ee28bb1",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/spice_kernels/pck/pck00011.tpc"
    },
    {
      "filename": "art002_rec_260402_260410_jsc_bet_revf.bsp",
      "bytes": 5693440,
      "sha256": "b8b3ebc4d703c3a73c9651b9da36114c3ef0b2c75f92873dd4970f32367aa7be",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/spice_kernels/spk/art002_rec_260402_260410_jsc_bet_revf.bsp"
    },
    {
      "filename": "art002_rec_260402_260410_jsc_bet_revf_gapfill.bsp",
      "bytes": 50176,
      "sha256": "ac9e3f21302a6a510757fff41a9f8a55df907b75fb2142b8fdfc44a599ddc9b9",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/spice_kernels/spk/art002_rec_260402_260410_jsc_bet_revf_gapfill.bsp"
    },
    {
      "filename": "earth_topo_260814.tf",
      "bytes": 69400,
      "sha256": "4f40cd1e86718047bc8ea6ff6bd063c9fbf36102b63f0dca370c8e94fd282490",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/spice_kernels/fk/earth_topo_260814.tf"
    },
    {
      "filename": "CAMRAS_Dwingeloo_20260408.tdm",
      "bytes": 1010415,
      "sha256": "234f382811bce93bb3d428f6cc173dcf575e94c8d469b2cb9b561b711aabdee6",
      "url": "https://data.camras.nl/artemis2/CAMRAS_Dwingeloo_20260408.tdm"
    },
    {
      "filename": "CAMRAS_Dwingeloo_20260409.tdm",
      "bytes": 887808,
      "sha256": "227043205f794a567e2e11f3c8a89f77f3cd984bc7bf7a4ef900d9a1122d6f93",
      "url": "https://data.camras.nl/artemis2/CAMRAS_Dwingeloo_20260409.tdm"
    }
  ],
  "credit": "CAMRAS Dwingeloo Radio Telescope; TDM measurements reused under CC BY 4.0. Frequency model, filtering to first metadata segment, fitted offsets and figures by Babylon Learning Centre. NASA/JPL NAIF reconstructed trajectory and SPICE Toolkit used.",
  "limits": [
    "Carrier offsets are fitted nuisance parameters, not measured hardware corrections. Different offsets on the two days preclude assuming one universal calibration.",
    "The same nominal carrier, approximate station and fixed first-order model are used both days; first half fits one offset and later half is held out. This does not create independent mission-level validation.",
    "Public navigation pedigree lists GPS, DSN, JAXA and SSC inputs. Whether CAMRAS data were directly or indirectly used is not established.",
    "No measurement uncertainty, statistical independence, significance threshold or complete propagation/relativistic error budget is established.",
    "Position and velocity covariance entries exist, but their units, frame, correlations, interpretation and appropriate projection need verification before a confidence band is used."
  ],
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "camras",
      "title": "CAMRAS Artemis II tracking archive",
      "url": "https://data.camras.nl/artemis2/",
      "role": "Outside receiver measurements, TDM metadata and CC BY 4.0 reuse licence."
    },
    {
      "id": "graph",
      "title": "CAMRAS interactive frequency graph",
      "url": "https://data.camras.nl/artemis2/frequency_plot.html",
      "role": "The observer’s own visualization and model-subtraction view; Babylon’s screen is separately calculated."
    },
    {
      "id": "sigmf",
      "title": "CAMRAS demonstration recording metadata",
      "url": "https://data.camras.nl/artemis2/demonstration_crop.sigmf-meta",
      "role": "An April 2 example declares external reference and PPS timing. It does not establish calibration for our April 8–9 intervals."
    },
    {
      "id": "monument",
      "title": "CAMRAS telescope monument record",
      "url": "https://www.camras.nl/en/about-the-radio-telescope/national-monument/",
      "role": "Site identification and published X–Y location lead. Our geodetic point remains an approximation, not a certified phase centre."
    },
    {
      "id": "spice",
      "title": "NASA/JPL NAIF · Artemis II SPICE bundle",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/",
      "role": "Public kernels; bundle DOI 10.17189/7ezn-0294. RevF SPK internal comments provide pedigree, contacts and OEM covariance entries."
    },
    {
      "id": "spk",
      "title": "NAIF spacecraft trajectory files and labels",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/pds/pds4/artemis2/artemis2_spice/spice_kernels/spk/",
      "role": "Exact RevF and gapfill filenames, labels and downloadable binary kernels. Internal comments inspected using the SPICE DAF comment reader."
    },
    {
      "id": "toolkit",
      "title": "NAIF SPKCPO · reception geometry documentation",
      "url": "https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/toolkit_docs/C/cspice/spkcpo_c.html",
      "role": "Observer-fixed position, state and converged light-time calculation. Does not supply transmitter calibration."
    },
    {
      "id": "pds",
      "title": "PDS Geosciences · Artemis II mission archive",
      "url": "https://pds-geosciences.wustl.edu/missions/artemis2/index.htm",
      "role": "Science bundles, user guide and mission dates; its delayed-SPICE notice remained visible during this review despite downloadable NAIF kernels."
    },
    {
      "id": "return",
      "title": "NASA · Artemis II return announcement",
      "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-welcomes-record-setting-artemis-ii-moonfarers-back-to-earth/",
      "role": "Mission summary and 695,081-mile total; published April 10, later updated May 7."
    },
    {
      "id": "initial",
      "title": "NASA · initial Artemis II assessments",
      "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/missions/nasa-on-track-for-future-missions-with-initial-artemis-ii-assessments/",
      "role": "April 20 report: 694,481 miles and 2.9 miles from targeted landing site."
    },
    {
      "id": "shield",
      "title": "NASA · October Artemis II heat-shield analysis",
      "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/missions/artemis/artemis-2/rigorous-analysis-confirms-nasas-artemis-ii-heat-shield-performance/",
      "role": "October 15 report, updated October 19: 0.59 miles from predicted landing site; inspection summaries and changed entry design."
    },
    {
      "id": "apollo",
      "title": "Apollo 11 Mission Report · NASA Technical Reports Server",
      "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19700008096",
      "role": "November 1969 mission report, MSC-00171, §7.5, printed pp.7-4–7-5. Entry reconstruction and its observational limitations."
    },
    {
      "id": "radiation",
      "title": "DLR · Artemis II M42 radiation-measurement abstract",
      "url": "https://elib.dlr.de/229158/",
      "role": "November 2026 poster record. Abstract reviewed; numerical measurements, poster and calibration files not obtained here."
    }
  ],
  "story": [
    {
      "title": "The question begins with a journey.",
      "text": "Babylon began by asking how a spacecraft could leave Earth’s atmosphere, travel toward the Moon and return through the atmosphere. To make that question answerable, we follow a chain: a dated mission claim, the instruments that could record it, the measurements they retained, the model used to interpret them and the uncertainty left at the end. A photograph, a reconstructed position and a radio-frequency measurement each contribute a different piece."
    },
    {
      "title": "Apollo gives us a historical record to inspect.",
      "text": "The Apollo 11 report describes an inoperative onboard recorder during entry and limits in the tracking available through the communications blackout. That explains why portions of the entry story require reconstruction. It does not mean that every mission record is missing. We keep the older inquiry focused on named entry inputs, the Best Estimated Trajectory and comparable radiation quantities."
    },
    {
      "title": "Artemis gives us a modern comparison, with a different destination.",
      "text": "Artemis II flew around the Moon in April 2026; Apollo 11 landed there in July 1969. Different paths, spacecraft and entry plans should produce different records. We compare how each claim can be traced rather than expecting identical flight numbers. For Artemis, a public reconstructed trajectory and an outside telescope’s frequency files let us begin a small repeatable test."
    },
    {
      "title": "The receiver provides a test of changing motion.",
      "text": "A radio carrier shifts in frequency as the line-of-sight motion between transmitter and receiver changes. Earth’s rotation moves the telescope too, and the signal arrives after a light-travel delay. We accounted for those geometric effects and selected only the first declared one-way interval on each of two nights. Later intervals name a Deep Space Network transmitter and need a different, two-leg signal model."
    },
    {
      "title": "The result narrows the question.",
      "text": "The two observed frequency curves broadly follow the calculated changes once a separate constant offset is fitted for each night. The remaining differences are small compared with the overall trend, but they contain time structure and cannot yet be assigned to spacecraft motion. Unknown carrier offsets, receiver processing, atmosphere, relativistic frequency transfer and trajectory uncertainty still need to be brought into the same calculation."
    },
    {
      "title": "The next chapter is an answerable request.",
      "text": "Our contribution is a public bridge between records: exact filenames, clocks, units, assumptions, plots and questions. We ask the data authors for the calibration and product references that would let another reader repeat a stronger test. A reply may close a gap, identify a different custodian or show that a particular record was not retained. Each outcome is documented in its own terms; none is pre-labelled concealment."
    }
  ],
  "gaps": [
    {
      "id": "receiver",
      "title": "Receiver and carrier calibration",
      "evidence": "The two fitted early-half offsets are about −2,250.70 Hz and −2,195.52 Hz. A carrier/reference offset can mimic an absolute Doppler difference.",
      "needed": "Phase-centre coordinates, UTC/frequency reference uncertainty, true transmitted carrier/mode, processing flags and the TDM TRANSMIT_FREQ_1 convention.",
      "route": "CAMRAS data authors",
      "status": "Sent 15 November 2026 · reply pending"
    },
    {
      "id": "lineage",
      "title": "Trajectory uncertainty and tracking lineage",
      "evidence": "RevF comments name GPS, DSN, JAXA and SSC tracking, and include 13,186 covariance epoch entries.",
      "needed": "Covariance units/frame and projection guidance; public OEM and measurement-product references; whether CAMRAS measurements informed the solution.",
      "route": "JSC navigation author; NAIF file author copied",
      "status": "Sent 15 November 2026 · reply pending"
    },
    {
      "id": "coverage",
      "title": "Before separation and after entry interface",
      "evidence": "The inspected RevF kernel starts April 2 at 01:58:21.397 UTC and ends April 10 at 23:53:24.643 UTC. Its notes identify separation-to-entry-interface scope.",
      "needed": "The named public product covering launch-to-separation and entry-interface-to-splashdown, or the responsible custodian.",
      "route": "Included with navigation-author question",
      "status": "Sent 15 November 2026 · reply pending"
    },
    {
      "id": "numbers",
      "title": "Reconcile two published summary differences",
      "evidence": "Two NASA articles give 695,081 and 694,481 total miles. April and October assessments give 2.9 miles from targeted and 0.59 miles from predicted landing site.",
      "needed": "Definitions, coordinate/time/frame references and revision history. The two landing-reference phrases may name different points.",
      "route": "Mission reporting or navigation referral",
      "status": "Documented · not separately requested"
    },
    {
      "id": "radiation",
      "title": "Compare the same radiation quantity",
      "evidence": "A DLR poster abstract describes Artemis II M42 instruments; its numerical dose tables were not obtained in this review. Apollo readouts and assessed dose have their own definitions.",
      "needed": "Public numerical products, calibration, shielding/position and time intervals, with absorbed/equivalent/effective dose distinguished.",
      "route": "HERA/M42 authors and archive references",
      "status": "Lead located · numerical products pending"
    },
    {
      "id": "thermal",
      "title": "Move from inspection summary to measurement",
      "evidence": "NASA’s October article reports heat-shield findings and continued laser-scan analysis. A summary is not a complete thermal/ablation dataset.",
      "needed": "Released sensor timelines, Avcoat maps and recession/model uncertainty products, if publicly available.",
      "route": "Engineering archive or mission data custodian",
      "status": "Public summary reviewed · product search open"
    },
    {
      "id": "access",
      "title": "Separate a discovery gap from an access restriction",
      "evidence": "The PDS landing page still described SPICE as delayed while the NAIF bundle and trajectory files were downloadable.",
      "needed": "Reconcile the catalogue notice with the data location. For any actual denial, retain the record identifier, stated basis and review route.",
      "route": "PDS/NAIF catalogue maintainers",
      "status": "Public files obtained · stale notice observed"
    }
  ],
  "outreach": {
    "reviewed": "2026-11-15",
    "status": "Two inquiries sent · replies pending",
    "note": "Dated correspondence snapshot, not a live inbox. Incoming private messages and headers are not published. No paid work, reproduction order or FOIA filing is authorized by these questions.",
    "questions": [
      {
        "institution": "CAMRAS / Dwingeloo",
        "subject": "Artemis II April 8–9 radio calibration",
        "questions": [
          "Which station phase centre, UTC standard and frequency-reference accuracy apply to the April 8–9 TDM files?",
          "Are the first PATH=1,2 intervals free-running one-way carrier; what true transmit frequency and stability information is available?",
          "What does TRANSMIT_FREQ_1 represent in the coherent three-participant segments, and are uplink ramps/lock-state records public?",
          "Which estimator, flags and timing conventions produced the received-frequency rows, and were these data supplied to navigation teams?"
        ]
      },
      {
        "institution": "NASA JSC navigation / JPL NAIF",
        "subject": "Artemis II RevF uncertainty and tracking-product references",
        "questions": [
          "What are the covariance frame, units, epoch convention and interpretation, and where is the public OEM or a recommended projection example?",
          "Which released measurement/ramp products support a radio residual calculation; did CAMRAS observations enter RevF directly or indirectly?",
          "Which products cover launch-to-separation and entry-interface-to-splashdown outside this kernel’s declared scope?",
          "Is there a recommended frequency-transfer and clock convention for a ground-receiver comparison with this reconstruction?"
        ]
      }
    ]
  }
}