{
  "research_date": "2026-11-15",
  "scope": "Eight-task research continuation; no app design or publication",
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "BIBLE",
      "title": "Hebrew Bible: primary passages",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/texts/Tanakh",
      "location": "Genesis 1; 11; 14; 15; 49; Exodus 2; 24; 28; 31; Isaiah 43:7; 57:15; Jeremiah 1:5; Ezekiel 1:14; Job 26:7; Proverbs 3:19–20",
      "access": "Hebrew checked against package corpus and/or the selected Sefer Yetzirah quotations; English glosses in this report are our working translations.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "JUB",
      "title": "Jubilees, R. H. Charles translation",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Book_of_Jubilees.12",
      "location": "12:25–27 in Charles’s verse numbering",
      "access": "Complete selected English passage checked; Ethiopic-based translation. The modern Hebrew on Sefaria is not an ancient Hebrew manuscript.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "JUBDATE",
      "title": "James M. Scott, On Earth as in Heaven (2004), introduction",
      "url": "https://brill.com/display/book/9789047405115/front-4.pdf",
      "location": "Introduction: composition and manuscript witnesses",
      "access": "Publisher-hosted introduction/search extract; used for the second-century BCE work and ancient Hebrew Qumran witnesses, not a claim that 12:25–27 survives in a particular fragment.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "PHILO1",
      "title": "Philo, Life of Moses I, C. D. Yonge translation",
      "url": "https://www.earlyjewishwritings.com/text/philo/book24.html",
      "location": "I.4; I.20–24",
      "access": "Selected primary passage checked in full; public-domain translation. First-century CE portrayal, not a contemporary school record.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "PHILO2",
      "title": "Philo, Life of Moses II, C. D. Yonge translation",
      "url": "https://www.earlyjewishwritings.com/text/philo/book25.html",
      "location": "II.122–127",
      "access": "Selected primary passage checked; breastplate, seasons, zodiac and two modes of reason.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "JOSEPHUS",
      "title": "Josephus, Antiquities III, W. Whiston translation",
      "url": "https://penelope.uchicago.edu/josephus/ant-3.html",
      "location": "III.168, 186",
      "access": "Original Whiston text rechecked at the twelve stones/months/zodiac passage, with comparison to Philo. A twelvefold interpretation, not a complete month-by-tribe assignment.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "EUSEBIUS",
      "title": "Eusebius, Preparation for the Gospel IX, E. H. Gifford (1903)",
      "url": "https://www.tertullian.org/fathers/eusebius_pe_09_book9.htm",
      "location": "IX.16–18; IX.26–28",
      "access": "Selected primary fragments checked. Eusebius preserves earlier authors, often through Alexander Polyhistor; these are dependent chains, not independent contemporary witnesses.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "BER",
      "title": "Babylonian Talmud, Berakhot 55a",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Berakhot.55a.13",
      "location": "55a, lemma יודע היה בצלאל לצרף אותיות",
      "access": "Exact Hebrew downloaded; named inference from Exodus 31:3 and Proverbs 3:19–20. Current print text, not manuscript collation.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "SAN",
      "title": "Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 65b",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Sanhedrin.65b.18",
      "location": "65b, R. Hanina and R. Oshaya; compare 67b",
      "access": "Current Hebrew print names Sefer Yetzirah. Identification and alternate wording require manuscript-level control; no date inferred for the extant book from this alone.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "RASHI",
      "title": "Rashi on Sanhedrin 65b",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Rashi_on_Sanhedrin.65b.17",
      "location": "ברא גברא — על ידי ספר יצירה…",
      "access": "Exact Hebrew checked. Late-eleventh-century commentary; explicit named-book/Name-letter interpretation.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "GR",
      "title": "Genesis Rabbah 43:6",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Bereishit_Rabbah.43.6",
      "location": "הִלְכוֹת כְּהֻנָּה גְדוֹלָה גִּלָּה לוֹ / תּוֹרָה גִּלָּה לוֹ",
      "access": "Hebrew checked; English translations below are our short working glosses. Two interpretations of bread/wine.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "NED",
      "title": "Babylonian Talmud, Nedarim 32b",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Nedarim.32b",
      "location": "ביקש הקדוש ברוך הוא להוציא כהונה משם; subsequent Abraham argument",
      "access": "Downloaded vocalized edition places passage at :6–7; some cached search numbering points to :10. Cite daf + lemma rather than assuming segment concordance.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "IAA",
      "title": "Israel Antiquities Authority: 11Q13",
      "url": "https://www.deadseascrolls.org.il/explore-the-archive/manuscript/11Q13-1",
      "location": "11QMelchizedek, column II",
      "access": "Institutional record checked. Web text exposes catalogue shell, not a complete diplomatic transcription; no new image decipherment claimed.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "11QSCH",
      "title": "Andrzej Paweł Cekiera, Interpretation of Scriptural Texts in 11QMelchizedek (2021)",
      "url": "https://bibliotekanauki.pl/articles/1623332.pdf",
      "location": "11Q13 II.2–4, 6, 9–13; scriptural interpretation",
      "access": "Original article pp.411–415 and its scriptural-locus table checked; damaged text and editorial reconstructions kept separate. Cekiera reports50–25BCE; other scholars propose earlier first-century ranges. No restoration is treated as visible ink.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "1Q20",
      "title": "Israel Museum, Genesis Retold",
      "url": "https://www.imj.org.il/en/exhibitions/genesis-retold-0",
      "location": "Genesis Apocryphon, 1Q20",
      "access": "Museum dates the scroll to late first century BCE and records discovery in 1947. Selected Melchizedek locus XXII.14–17 is a follow-up transcription target, not a new collation here.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "HAYMAN",
      "title": "A. Peter Hayman, Sefer Yeṣira (2004), publisher preview",
      "url": "https://api.pageplace.de/preview/DT0400.9783161587955_A40613273/preview-9783161587955_A40613273.pdf",
      "location": "Introduction pp.1–4; contents and witness discussion",
      "access": "Only the 22-page preview was available. Full synoptic text/critical apparatus not read. Modern scholarship quoted nowhere at length.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "CAM",
      "title": "Ben Outhwaite, Cambridge Genizah Fragments 50 (October 2005)",
      "url": "https://wwwe.lib.cam.ac.uk/GF/50/",
      "location": "Establishing reliability of texts",
      "access": "Institutional confirmation of joined roll T-S K21.56 + T-S 32.5 + T-S 12.813, probably tenth century.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "CAMCAT",
      "title": "National Library of Israel, Ktiv record",
      "url": "https://www.nli.org.il/en/discover/manuscripts/hebrew-manuscripts/itempage?docId=PNX_MANUSCRIPTS990051214940205171&scope=PNX_MANUSCRIPTS&vid=MANUSCRIPTS",
      "location": "Cambridge T-S K 21.56",
      "access": "Catalogue identification verified; not an independent historical witness alongside its own edition.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "VAT",
      "title": "Vatican Library, Vat. ebr. 299",
      "url": "https://digi.vatlib.it/view/MSS_Vat.ebr.299",
      "location": "Sefer Yetzirah, ff.66a–71b",
      "access": "Digital object identified; folio-level independent collation not completed. Hayman’s A; long recension.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "BA",
      "title": "Avishai Bar-Asher, Tarbiz 89 (2023), pp.231–323",
      "url": "https://jstudies.huji.ac.il/sites/default/files/jstudies/files/tarbiz_-_8902_-_book.pdf",
      "location": "Critical appendix pp.312–323, especially 313, 318–319, 321, 323",
      "access": "Selected appendix loci rendered and visually checked. Edition has supplements, deletions and displaced units; the editor’s reconstruction is not an autograph. Article argues Genizah prototype → long → short, a contested genealogy.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "BEN",
      "title": "Naama Ben-Shachar, Teʿuda 34 (2025), pp.101–149",
      "url": "https://humanities.tau.ac.il/sites/humanities.tau.ac.il/files/media_server/all-units/%D7%91%D7%99%D7%AA%20%D7%A1%D7%A4%D7%A8%20%D7%9C%D7%9E%D7%93%D7%A2%D7%99%20%D7%94%D7%99%D7%94%D7%93%D7%95%D7%AA/%D7%AA%D7%A2%D7%95%D7%93%D7%94-%20%D7%9B%D7%A8%D7%9B%D7%99%D7%9D/%D7%AA%D7%A2%D7%95%D7%93%D7%94-%20%D7%9B%D7%A8%D7%9A%20%D7%9C%D7%93/vol_34/06_Ben_Shachar.pdf",
      "location": "221/231: pp.104–113, 143–146",
      "access": "Selected discussion and summary checked; printed p.144 rendered. Different gate counts can count different combinatorial objects. No ritual efficacy inferred.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "LAMBERT",
      "title": "Saadia’s recension, Mayer Lambert (1891), primary-edition reproduction",
      "url": "https://www.biblioj.fr/saadia-gaon-sefer-yetzira-lambert-traduction/",
      "location": "1:1; 2:3; 4:4; 5:4; 8:24",
      "access": "Hebrew lemmata and French primary translation checked online. Website’s modern introduction is not used as historical authority. Printed scan not independently collated.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "SY",
      "title": "Sefer Yetzirah, Warsaw 1884 text at Sefaria",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Sefer_Yetzirah",
      "location": "1:1, 1:8; 2:2–5; 4:3, 4:5–11; 5:1–2; 6:4",
      "access": "Hebrew checked. English community translation occasionally disagrees with Hebrew order (Samekh/Ayin) and contains directional slips; tables below use checked Hebrew.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "GRA",
      "title": "Sefer Yetzirah, Gra version, Hebrew text at Sefaria",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Sefer_Yetzirah_Gra_Version",
      "location": "4:8–14; 5:7–10",
      "access": "Hebrew checked; later received arrangement associated with Elijah of Vilna (1720–1797), not a manuscript of Abraham’s era. Tables use Hebrew, not Kaplan’s copyrighted English wording.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "DUN",
      "title": "Dunash ibn Tamim, commentary on Sefer Yetzirah, 955/6",
      "url": "https://www.posenlibrary.com/entry/commentary-book-creation-sefer-yetsirah-1",
      "location": "Chapter 1 selections, phonetics and number one",
      "access": "Primary commentary excerpt checked through published translation. Multiple Hebrew translations survive from a Judaeo-Arabic original; excerpt is not full critical edition.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "DON",
      "title": "Piergabriele Mancuso, Shabbatai Donnolo’s Sefer Hakhmoni (2010)",
      "url": "https://www.academia.edu/6857435/The_Sefer_Hakmoni_by_Shabbatai_Donnolo_Introduction_Critical_Hebrew_Text_and_Annotated_English_Translation_413_pp_Brill_Leiden_Boston_2010",
      "location": "Preface; introduction pp.12–30; contents point to critical text pp.137–207, translation pp.221–357",
      "access": "Author-posted introductory extract consulted, not the whole critical commentary. Oxford Heb.e.26 and 946/982 distinctions require full edition/image follow-through.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "DONTABLE",
      "title": "Sacha Stern and Piergabriele Mancuso, An Astronomical Table by Shabbetai Donnolo (2007)",
      "url": "https://www.jstor.org/stable/40377861",
      "location": "Aleph 7, pp.13–41",
      "access": "Original study identified; published abstract records an Elul/Safar 946 ephemeris in Oxford Heb.e.26. A table’s epoch is not by itself the date of every section.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "BAHIR",
      "title": "Sefer ha-Bahir, Hebrew at Sefaria",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Sefer_HaBahir.94",
      "location": "§§94–95 (this edition’s numbering)",
      "access": "Hebrew checked. Names/stones/tribes and twelve boundaries; not a full twelve-month tribe order in these sections.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "RAMNUM",
      "title": "Ramban on Numbers 2:2",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Ramban_on_Numbers.2.2",
      "location": "central sanctuary; והיכל קדש מכוון באמצע",
      "access": "Hebrew and commentary checked. Medieval explicit citation. Chavel’s note says he did not find the wording; it is present in the selected SY 4:3, Lambert 2:3 and Genizah-based B5. Don’t confuse translator’s note with Ramban’s words.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "RAMDEUT",
      "title": "Ramban on Deuteronomy 33:6",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Ramban_on_Deuteronomy.33.6",
      "location": "twelve tribes/months/constellations/boundaries",
      "access": "Selected passage checked. Explains inclusion/exclusion to maintain twelve; no immutable list of twelve names across all biblical contexts.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "BN",
      "title": "Bnei Yissaschar, Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov",
      "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Bnei_Yissaschar%2C_Tamuz_and_Av.1.3",
      "location": "Nisan 1:4; Iyar 1:9; Tamuz and Av 1:3; Tishrei 1:1; Cheshvan 1:2–3; Shevat 1:8",
      "access": "Hebrew sections checked. Nineteenth-century interpretation; complete camp-order synthesis below is labelled a derived table. Explicitly acknowledges older variant versions in Nisan 1:4.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "BMSTONE",
      "title": "British Museum, Shabaka Stone transcript",
      "url": "https://www.britishmuseum.org/sites/default/files/2022-11/Shabaka_Stone_transcript_Hieroglyphs_unlocking_ancient_Egypt_The_British_Musuem.pdf",
      "location": "EA498, heart/tongue/artisans",
      "access": "Official selected translation checked; ≤25 modern English words quoted in report.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "BMDATE",
      "title": "British Museum, Shabako Stone collection interpretation",
      "url": "https://artsandculture.google.com/asset/the-shabako-stone/_QGccGHkd8pyng?hl=en",
      "location": "EA498, c.710 BCE",
      "access": "Museum-contributed record: surviving stone, older-exemplar claim, archaizing presentation and millstone damage.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "PIRES",
      "title": "Guilherme Borges Pires, Of Creator and Creation (2020)",
      "url": "https://www.ull.es/revistas/index.php/trabajos-egiptologia/article/download/5087/3465",
      "location": "TdE 11, pp.263–284; texts16,17,28; Harris I 44.2–8",
      "access": "Selected New Kingdom passages and dating discussion checked in full article. Report distinguishes composition estimates from dates of surviving carriers.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "LEIDEN",
      "title": "Jan Zandee, De hymnen aan Amon van Papyrus Leiden I 350 (1947)",
      "url": "https://www.rmo.nl/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/NR_28_1947_1-158_-_Zandee_De_hymnen_aan_Amon_van_Papyrus_Leiden_I_350-1.pdf",
      "location": "Introduction, acquisition and dated verso",
      "access": "Museum-hosted original edition introduction checked through indexed text: purchased January 1829; findspot unknown; verso dated year52 of Ramesses II; hymn hand comparable.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "HARRIS",
      "title": "British Museum, Great Harris Papyrus scene",
      "url": "https://artsandculture.google.com/asset/scene-from-the-great-harris-papyrus-ramesses-iii-before-the-gods-of-memphis/RwFvCO_jiAa68Q?hl=en",
      "location": "EA9999, c.1150 BCE",
      "access": "Museum-contributed object date; separate from Pires’s proposed date for hymn composition.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "HARING",
      "title": "Ben Haring, Ancient Egypt and the earliest known stages of alphabetic writing",
      "url": "https://scholarlypublications.universiteitleiden.nl/handle/1887/3295773",
      "location": "2019/2020 publication, pp.53–67",
      "access": "Leiden catalogue gives2019; author offprint cites2020. Open-access chapter read, especially Sinai345/acrophony and disputed dating/sign inventory.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "AREN",
      "title": "Aren Wilson-Wright, Interpreting the Sinaitic Inscriptions in Context (2013)",
      "url": "https://sites.utexas.edu/scripts/wp-content/uploads/sites/3428/2016/07/aren_2013.pdf",
      "location": "HeBAI 2, pp.136–148; Sinai345/BM EA41748",
      "access": "Original author offprint checked. Partial bilingual context does not require the same writer for both scripts.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "AMARNA",
      "title": "Nadav Na’aman, Jerusalem in the Amarna Period (2011)",
      "url": "https://www.academia.edu/12995930/Jerusalem_in_the_Amarna_Period_in_C_Arnould_B%C3%A9har_and_A_Lemaire_eds_J%C3%A9rusalem_antique_et_m%C3%A9di%C3%A9vale_M%C3%A9langes_en_l_honneur_d_Ernest_Marie_Laperrousaz_Paris_Louvaine_and_Walpole_2011_31_48",
      "location": "EA286:9–13; EA287:25–28; EA288:13–15",
      "access": "Original scholarly treatment identified; Egyptian appointment claim, not parentless biology. No new complete tablet collation.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "KH",
      "title": "Barkay, Lundberg, Vaughn and Zuckerman, Ketef Hinnom edition (2004)",
      "url": "https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.2307/4150106",
      "location": "BASOR334, pp.41–71",
      "access": "Original excavation/re-reading study’s abstract checked; discovery1979, archaeology and palaeography distinguish carrier dates from whole-book dates.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "NASH",
      "title": "Cambridge University Library, Nash Papyrus",
      "url": "https://artsandculture.google.com/asset/nash-papyrus-ms-or-233/GAFM9Yy6A4XRkA?hl=en",
      "location": "MS Or.233",
      "access": "Institutional record checked: second-century BCE, bought1902/presented1903; reputed Fayyum provenance uncertain. Decalogue+Shema, not complete Torah.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "ACTS",
      "title": "Codex Sinaiticus, selected physical-witness reference",
      "url": "https://manuscripts.csntm.org/manuscript/Group/GA_01",
      "location": "GA01, Greek New Testament, fourth century",
      "access": "Institutional manuscript catalogue identifies the codex/date. Exact Acts7image was not collated; not claimed as earliest surviving exact passage.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "BAHIRCOPY",
      "title": "Bavarian State Library, Hebrew collections",
      "url": "https://www.bsb-muenchen.de/sammlungen/orient/sprachen/hebraeisch-und-jiddisch/",
      "location": "Cod.hebr.209",
      "access": "Institutional collection identifies the kabbalistic codex and Scholem’s work;1298date comes from the reported critical manuscript description, not a new colophon transcription.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    },
    {
      "id": "WEISS",
      "title": "Tzahi Weiss, Sefer Yeṣirah and Its Contexts (2018)",
      "url": "https://www.pennpress.org/9780812249903/sefer-yeirah-and-its-contexts/",
      "location": "Publisher description; chapter3 Syriac context; chapter4 prior to tenth century",
      "access": "Research thesis identified via original publisher, not full book read: seventh-century composition/Syriac context proposal; disagreement retained.",
      "checked": "2026-11-15"
    }
  ],
  "claims": [
    {
      "id": "C01",
      "title": "Royal adoption is the biblical starting point",
      "classification": "Direct statement",
      "statement": "Pharaoh’s daughter takes Moses as her son. The verse does not list his subjects of study.",
      "passage": "Exodus2:10",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Separates biblical foundation from later expanded biography.",
      "unresolved": "Narrated event has no independently dated Egyptian school dossier here."
    },
    {
      "id": "C02",
      "title": "A named Egyptian education tradition",
      "classification": "Later historical retelling",
      "statement": "Acts7:21–22 says Moses was educated in Egyptian wisdom; Philo lists mathematical, musical, symbolic and celestial subjects.",
      "passage": "Acts7:21–22; Philo I.20–24",
      "sources": [
        "PHILO1",
        "BIBLE"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Royal education is a real documented tradition, not a newly invented bridge.",
      "unresolved": "No 22/231/32 syllabus; agreement does not prove Philo and Acts independent of shared tradition."
    },
    {
      "id": "C03",
      "title": "Abraham, Hebrew and ancestral books",
      "classification": "Traditional attribution",
      "statement": "An angel enables Abraham to speak Hebrew, the language of creation, and understand ancestral books.",
      "passage": "Jubilees12:25–27 (Charles)",
      "sources": [
        "JUB",
        "JUBDATE"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Provides a Second Temple Abraham–creation-language strand earlier than the surviving Yetzirah copies.",
      "unresolved": "Exact verses not matched to a surviving Hebrew Qumran fragment in this audit; no gates or32 paths in the passage."
    },
    {
      "id": "C04",
      "title": "Abraham teaches Egypt",
      "classification": "Traditional attribution",
      "statement": "Josephus and a fragment attributed to Eupolemus portray Abraham teaching celestial/mathematical knowledge in Egypt; the latter traces it to Enoch and also mentions Melchizedek.",
      "passage": "Eusebius PE IX.16–18",
      "sources": [
        "EUSEBIUS"
      ],
      "what_changes": "The literary transmission arrow can run Abraham→Egypt, opposite the assumed single arrow.",
      "unresolved": "Pseudo-Eupolemus attribution is disputed; text is mediated by later quotations and localizes the encounter at Gerizim."
    },
    {
      "id": "C05",
      "title": "Moses teaches Egypt",
      "classification": "Traditional attribution",
      "statement": "Artapanus makes Moses a civilizing inventor and interpreter of sacred writing; Eupolemus credits Moses with teaching letters.",
      "passage": "Eusebius PE IX.26–27",
      "sources": [
        "EUSEBIUS"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Ancient Jewish authors claimed cultural priority as well as Egyptian education.",
      "unresolved": "Literary cultural-hero narratives do not identify the inventor of the excavated alphabet."
    },
    {
      "id": "C06",
      "title": "The explicit Bezalel inference",
      "classification": "Later interpretation",
      "statement": "The Talmud joins wisdom, understanding and knowledge in Exodus31:3 to Proverbs3:19–20, attributing creation-letter combination to Bezalel.",
      "passage": "Berakhot55a",
      "sources": [
        "BER"
      ],
      "what_changes": "This is a documented exegetical bridge from craftsmanship to creation letters.",
      "unresolved": "It names Bezalel, not a Mosaic course or a231-gate inventory."
    },
    {
      "id": "C07",
      "title": "Named book and formation stories",
      "classification": "Textual variant / later interpretation",
      "statement": "The current Sanhedrin print names Sefer Yetzirah; Rashi explicitly explains formation by the book and combinations of Name-letters.",
      "passage": "Sanhedrin65b; Rashi65b, ברא גברא",
      "sources": [
        "SAN",
        "RASHI"
      ],
      "what_changes": "The named-book link is explicit in the received tradition.",
      "unresolved": "Alternate manuscript wording and whether it denotes this extant treatise remain unresolved; not proof of physical creation by recitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "C08",
      "title": "Thirty-two is ten plus twenty-two",
      "classification": "Direct statement / arithmetic",
      "statement": "The opening associates32 wondrous paths with ten sefirot and22 letters, grouped3+7+12.",
      "passage": "SY opening; critical appendix p.313",
      "sources": [
        "SY",
        "LAMBERT",
        "BA"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Separates the32fold architecture from the231pair inventory.",
      "unresolved": "A later fixed drawing of a ten-node Tree and labelled edges is not supplied by this opening."
    },
    {
      "id": "C09",
      "title": "221 and231 are actual historical readings",
      "classification": "Manuscript/edition evidence",
      "statement": "The Genizah-based gate locus reads221; Lambert’s Saadyan text reads231; Ben-Shachar traces calculations and shifting distributions.",
      "passage": "Critical appendix p.318 D3; Lambert4:4; Teʿuda34",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "LAMBERT",
        "BEN"
      ],
      "what_changes": "No silent emendation. Babylon’s22-choose-2 arithmetic remains231.",
      "unresolved": "Full stemma of every gate locus is not collated; ritual claims do not establish efficacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "C10",
      "title": "Abraham’s ending changes across witnesses",
      "classification": "Manuscript/edition evidence",
      "statement": "The Genizah-based closing invokes Jeremiah1:5; the familiar6:4 supplies Genesis15:6, covenant and22letters.",
      "passage": "Critical appendix p.323 D8; SY6:4; Lambert8:24",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "SY",
        "LAMBERT"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Abraham remains present, while the revelation’s exact wording is version-specific.",
      "unresolved": "Does not independently date the teaching to the patriarch or show who wrote the treatise."
    },
    {
      "id": "C11",
      "title": "Babylon’s planetary order has a textual parallel",
      "classification": "Direct comparison",
      "statement": "The checked Genizah-based planet sequence agrees with Babylon’s ב Saturn…ת Moon. The Gra assignment sequence differs.",
      "passage": "Critical appendix p.319 D5; SY4; Gra4",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "SY",
        "GRA"
      ],
      "what_changes": "A historically attested correspondence can be retained without replacing the Babylon dictionary.",
      "unresolved": "Matching planets do not independently authenticate every psychological or physical claim attached to the letters."
    },
    {
      "id": "C12",
      "title": "Dunash interprets rather than merely repeats",
      "classification": "Later interpretation",
      "statement": "Dunash’s phonetic discussion selects Aleph–Yod–Vav as three light vowel letters and interprets number one differently from Saadia.",
      "passage": "Dunash, chapter1 selections",
      "sources": [
        "DUN"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Early commentators were not a single unchanged explanatory school.",
      "unresolved": "This is his phonetic argument, not permission to replace Babylon’s Aleph–Mem–Shin mothers."
    },
    {
      "id": "C13",
      "title": "Twelve tribes precede Moses in narrative order",
      "classification": "Direct statement",
      "statement": "Genesis49:28 calls Jacob’s sons twelve tribes; Exodus24:4 makes twelve covenant pillars; Exodus28:21 prescribes twelve stones.",
      "passage": "Genesis49:28; Exodus24:4;28:21",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE"
      ],
      "what_changes": "The Mosaic twelve has an explicit narrative inheritance.",
      "unresolved": "The verses do not themselves assign each tribe a zodiac sign."
    },
    {
      "id": "C14",
      "title": "Early cosmic interpretation of the breastplate",
      "classification": "Later interpretation",
      "statement": "Philo links the twelve breastplate stones/four rows to zodiac/seasons; Josephus offers months or zodiac as possible readings.",
      "passage": "Philo II.124–126; AntiquitiesIII.186",
      "sources": [
        "PHILO2",
        "JOSEPHUS"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Cosmic twelve is demonstrably Jewish and early Imperial, not only a recent table.",
      "unresolved": "Neither selected locus provides the complete modern letter→month→tribe table."
    },
    {
      "id": "C15",
      "title": "Medieval boundary, name and camp bridges",
      "classification": "Later interpretation",
      "statement": "Bahir connects tribes/stones/divine names and cosmic boundaries. Ramban explicitly cites Yetzirah for the centered sanctuary and relates twelve tribes to months/constellations.",
      "passage": "Bahir94–95; Ramban Numbers2:2; Deut33:6",
      "sources": [
        "BAHIR",
        "RAMNUM",
        "RAMDEUT"
      ],
      "what_changes": "There is an explicit medieval bridge, with identifiable quotations.",
      "unresolved": "A complete month-by-tribe order is not established by those selected passages."
    },
    {
      "id": "C16",
      "title": "A later explicit month–camp reading",
      "classification": "Later interpretation",
      "statement": "Bnei Yissaschar identifies months with tribes in the camp order and expressly recognizes textual variants of Yetzirah.",
      "passage": "Nisan1:4; Tamuz and Av1:3; Tishrei1:1",
      "sources": [
        "BN"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Supplies a dated reception witness for a usable complete camp-order synthesis.",
      "unresolved": "Do not backdate this nineteenth-century witness or infer it is the only older order."
    },
    {
      "id": "C17",
      "title": "Egyptian heart, tongue, writing and crafts",
      "classification": "Material witness / comparison",
      "statement": "Ptah’s heart devises, tongue commands, and crafts follow in the Shabaka text.",
      "passage": "BM EA498, heart/tongue passage",
      "sources": [
        "BMSTONE",
        "BMDATE"
      ],
      "what_changes": "The comparison has exact operations, not merely a shared sacred number.",
      "unresolved": "c.710BCE stone is not an Old Kingdom original; every hieroglyph is not a statement about22 Hebrew consonants."
    },
    {
      "id": "C18",
      "title": "Egyptian precursors before Shabaka",
      "classification": "Material witness / comparison",
      "statement": "LeidenI350 has self-formation and divine plurality/unity; HarrisI44 depicts the sky as conceived in Ptah’s heart and humans proceeding through his mouth.",
      "passage": "LeidenI350 III.22–24; IV.21–22; HarrisI44.2–8",
      "sources": [
        "PIRES",
        "LEIDEN",
        "HARRIS"
      ],
      "what_changes": "The broad conception/speech/craft motif is attested in New Kingdom sources, not dependent on Shabaka’s old-exemplar claim.",
      "unresolved": "No exact22/231/32 system or named historical transmitter recovered; hymn composition and papyrus-copy dates differ."
    },
    {
      "id": "C19",
      "title": "An actual Egyptian–Semitic writing contact",
      "classification": "Material witness / scholarship",
      "statement": "Sinai345 combines Egyptian and early alphabetic inscriptions. The likely acrophonic mechanism uses Semitic words for pictured objects.",
      "passage": "Sinai345/BM EA41748; Haringpp.54–58; Wilson-Wrightpp.136–138",
      "sources": [
        "HARING",
        "AREN"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Writing contact is physically evidenced.",
      "unresolved": "Sign inventory, exact dates/readings and single-versus-multiple writers disputed; not an esoteric curriculum or a Moses inscription."
    },
    {
      "id": "C20",
      "title": "Melchizedek meets Abraham",
      "classification": "Direct statement",
      "statement": "A king-priest brings bread and wine and blesses Abraham; the account reports a tithe, with the giver grammatically implicit in Genesis14:20.",
      "passage": "Genesis14:18–20",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Establishes the biblical encounter and priestly setting.",
      "unresolved": "No letter-school, gates or identity with Abdi-Heba stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "C21",
      "title": "Melchizedek teaches Abraham in midrash",
      "classification": "Traditional attribution",
      "statement": "Genesis Rabbah reads bread/wine as revealing high-priestly law or Torah; Nedarim identifies the Shem/priesthood strand.",
      "passage": "Genesis Rabbah43:6; Nedarim32b",
      "sources": [
        "GR",
        "NED"
      ],
      "what_changes": "A teacher→Abraham link is explicit in rabbinic tradition.",
      "unresolved": "Late-antique exegesis is not independent Bronze Age verification of a Yetzirah initiation."
    },
    {
      "id": "C22",
      "title": "Melchizedek’s other roles are not identical biographies",
      "classification": "Material witness / later interpretation",
      "statement": "11Q13 gives Melchizedek a jubilee/deliverance setting; Hebrews7 interprets the Genesis figure through priesthood.",
      "passage": "11Q13colII; Hebrews7",
      "sources": [
        "IAA",
        "11QSCH",
        "BIBLE"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Separates Second Temple eschatology and Christian priestly argument from the Genesis encounter.",
      "unresolved": "Missing genealogy is not documentary proof of a biologically parentless individual; no231gates in the selected loci."
    },
    {
      "id": "C23",
      "title": "Abdi-Heba is a different named witness",
      "classification": "Material witness / scholarship",
      "statement": "The Amarna letters concern a Jerusalem ruler’s appointment by Pharaoh rather than hereditary succession.",
      "passage": "EA286:9–13;287:25–28;288:13–15",
      "sources": [
        "AMARNA"
      ],
      "what_changes": "The no-father/no-mother wording has a political explanation.",
      "unresolved": "It does not identify Abdi-Heba with Melchizedek; a shared place or broad priestly setting is insufficient."
    },
    {
      "id": "C24",
      "title": "Four-world descent remains an attributed reading",
      "classification": "Proposed Babylon connection",
      "statement": "Isaiah43:7 supplies created/formed/made verbs; it does not name all four later worlds. The new audit has no explicit four-world labels.",
      "passage": "Isaiah43:7; audit0.9",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Supports comparison of operations while keeping textual stages separate from a later interpretive map.",
      "unresolved": "Atziluth/Beriah/Yetzirah/Assiyah sequence not established here as Moses’s explicit teaching; fifth layer undefined."
    },
    {
      "id": "C25",
      "title": "A stable spelling does not select one grammar",
      "classification": "Reproducible corpus observation",
      "statement": "נעשה occurs as Qal first-person-plural speech and as Niphal3ms prepared/made in Leviticus7:9.",
      "passage": "Audit0.9, seven exact-spelling tokens",
      "sources": [],
      "what_changes": "Context and morphology are required before assigning an event or agent.",
      "unresolved": "Not a blind prediction test or refutation of the author framework."
    },
    {
      "id": "C26",
      "title": "Speech can propose without accomplishing",
      "classification": "Reproducible corpus observation",
      "statement": "The sample includes promises, statutory descriptions, a blocked building project, quoted future refusal and diplomatic refusal.",
      "passage": "Audit0.9, all10selected tokens",
      "sources": [],
      "what_changes": "A successful speech→object story cannot be generalized to every token.",
      "unresolved": "No inference that absent stages were spiritually present; no moral scoring of a grieving person."
    },
    {
      "id": "C27",
      "title": "Visible early biblical wording is not a whole-book autograph",
      "classification": "Material witness",
      "statement": "Ketef Hinnom parallels Numbers6; Nash preserves Decalogue+Shema. Their carriers have dates independent of patriarchal/Mosaic narration.",
      "passage": "KH1/KH2; MS Or.233",
      "sources": [
        "KH",
        "NASH"
      ],
      "what_changes": "Makes archaeology useful at the exact-passage level.",
      "unresolved": "Neither dates all five Torah books or supplies a231gate manuscript."
    }
  ],
  "witnesses": [
    {
      "id": "W01",
      "witness": "Sinai345 / BM EA41748",
      "composition_estimate": "Second millennium BCE; dates disputed",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "The inscribed sphinx itself; proposed Middle/New Kingdom settings",
      "claimed_event_time": "Dedication within Egyptian/Semitic mining context",
      "traditional_attribution": "Not attributed to Abraham/Moses",
      "language": "Egyptian + early Northwest Semitic alphabetic",
      "provenance": "Hathor temple, Serabit el-Khadim; found1906",
      "passage": "bʿlt / Egyptian Hathor formula",
      "dating_basis": "Archaeological setting, object style, palaeography; not exact calendar date",
      "sources": [
        "HARING",
        "AREN"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Sign inventory and detailed reading; no22/231/32 scheme"
    },
    {
      "id": "W02",
      "witness": "LeidenI350",
      "composition_estimate": "Later RamessesII reign proposed",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Surviving papyrus, Ramesside hand; verso year52 of RamessesII",
      "claimed_event_time": "Creation at primordial time; not a human eyewitness date",
      "traditional_attribution": "Anonymous hymn collection",
      "language": "Egyptian, hieratic",
      "provenance": "Bought from Anastasy January1829; findspot unknown",
      "passage": "III.22–24; IV.21–22",
      "dating_basis": "Regnal date on verso + hand comparison",
      "sources": [
        "LEIDEN",
        "PIRES"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Date of hymn composition not identical to dated travel record"
    },
    {
      "id": "W03",
      "witness": "Great Harris Papyrus / EA9999",
      "composition_estimate": "Hymn may predate compilation; Pires proposes late RamessesIII",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Papyrus c.1150BCE / RamessesIV context",
      "claimed_event_time": "Primordial creation + RamessesIII deeds",
      "traditional_attribution": "Royal compilation, not Moses",
      "language": "Egyptian, hieratic",
      "provenance": "Theban association; BM; no verified excavation context supplied here",
      "passage": "44.2–8",
      "dating_basis": "Royal names, historical context and palaeography",
      "sources": [
        "PIRES",
        "HARRIS"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Separate hymn date from carrier; check full plate before claiming own Egyptian transcription"
    },
    {
      "id": "W04",
      "witness": "Amarna Jerusalem letters",
      "composition_estimate": "Fourteenth century BCE",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Clay tablets contemporary with correspondence",
      "claimed_event_time": "Fourteenth-century political conditions",
      "traditional_attribution": "Abdi-Heba / his scribes",
      "language": "Akkadian with Canaanite interference",
      "provenance": "Amarna archive; Berlin objects among witnesses",
      "passage": "EA286–288",
      "dating_basis": "Royal correspondents and archaeological/archive setting",
      "sources": [
        "AMARNA"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Museum-number concordance and full images remain to collate; no identification with Melchizedek"
    },
    {
      "id": "W05",
      "witness": "ShabakaStone / EA498",
      "composition_estimate": "Content’s earlier history disputed",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "c.710BCE surviving stone",
      "claimed_event_time": "Primordial creation; claims older damaged exemplar",
      "traditional_attribution": "Copy ordered by Shabaka",
      "language": "Egyptian, hieroglyphic",
      "provenance": "Memphis; later millstone reuse",
      "passage": "Heart/tongue/crafts passage",
      "dating_basis": "Royal reign, object and script; not independent proof of exemplar age",
      "sources": [
        "BMDATE",
        "BMSTONE"
      ],
      "unresolved": "No recovered worm-eaten original with secure older date"
    },
    {
      "id": "W06",
      "witness": "Ketef Hinnom amulets",
      "composition_estimate": "Blessing formula earlier than or current with inscription; whole-book composition not determined",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Late7th/early6th century BCE usual reading; date debate retained",
      "claimed_event_time": "Protection for wearer, not a narrated creation event",
      "traditional_attribution": "Anonymous inscribers",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Tomb repository, discovered1979",
      "passage": "Priestly-blessing wording close to Numbers6:24–26",
      "dating_basis": "Excavation context and palaeography; later-date arguments exist",
      "sources": [
        "KH"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Requires exact surviving/reconstructed letter apparatus; does not date whole Numbers"
    },
    {
      "id": "W07",
      "witness": "Torah literary traditions",
      "composition_estimate": "Layered first-millennium BCE composition/redaction debated; passage-specific dates not settled here",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Earliest complete/partial witness differs by locus; Nash is selected, not a complete Torah",
      "claimed_event_time": "Patriarchs/Moses traditionally placed in second millennium BCE, with differing chronologies",
      "traditional_attribution": "Mosaic Torah in religious tradition; anonymous literary formation in critical study",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Multiple transmission streams",
      "passage": "Gen14; Ex2; Ex24; Ex28; Ex31",
      "dating_basis": "Distinguish literary arguments from dated carriers",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE",
        "KH",
        "NASH"
      ],
      "unresolved": "No Moses autograph or contemporary reading list located; no single BCE year imposed"
    },
    {
      "id": "W08",
      "witness": "NashPapyrus / MS Or.233",
      "composition_estimate": "Liturgical compilation prior to copying; date of source passages not fixed",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Second century BCE",
      "claimed_event_time": "Decalogue narrated at Sinai",
      "traditional_attribution": "Anonymous copyist",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Bought Egypt1902; Cambridge gift1903; Fayyum report uncertain",
      "passage": "Decalogue + Shema",
      "dating_basis": "Palaeography / institutional catalogue",
      "sources": [
        "NASH"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Not whole Torah; source wording varies from later editions"
    },
    {
      "id": "W09",
      "witness": "Jubilees",
      "composition_estimate": "Second century BCE; narrower date disputed",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Hebrew Qumran fragments c.100BCE onward; complete version mainly later Ethiopic MSS",
      "claimed_event_time": "Creation through Moses; Abraham episode earlier in narrative",
      "traditional_attribution": "Angel’s revelation to Moses in literary frame; historical author unknown",
      "language": "Hebrew composition; complete Ethiopic translation",
      "provenance": "Qumran fragments; Ethiopic transmission",
      "passage": "12:25–27",
      "dating_basis": "Palaeography and intertextual/literary history",
      "sources": [
        "JUB",
        "JUBDATE"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Exact12:25–27 ancient Hebrew fragment not identified in this pass; do not quote modern Hebrew as original"
    },
    {
      "id": "W10",
      "witness": "Eupolemus / Pseudo-Eupolemus / Artapanus",
      "composition_estimate": "Hellenistic Jewish works, commonly second century BCE; authorship/layer dates differ",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Fragments through Polyhistor (first century BCE) and Eusebius (fourth century CE); earliest physical copy not verified here",
      "claimed_event_time": "Abraham/Moses in much earlier narrative setting",
      "traditional_attribution": "Named fragment authors; Eupolemus attribution disputed for IX.17",
      "language": "Greek",
      "provenance": "Literary quotation chain, not excavated Bronze Age record",
      "passage": "PE IX.17–18;26–28",
      "dating_basis": "Quoting authors and literary context",
      "sources": [
        "EUSEBIUS"
      ],
      "unresolved": "No surviving author autograph; dependency prevents counting each repetition as an independent witness"
    },
    {
      "id": "W11",
      "witness": "1Q20 / Genesis Apocryphon",
      "composition_estimate": "Second Temple work; precise composition estimate unresolved here",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Late first century BCE according to Israel Museum",
      "claimed_event_time": "Patriarchal Genesis narrative",
      "traditional_attribution": "Anonymous retelling in first-person voices",
      "language": "Aramaic",
      "provenance": "Qumran Cave1, discovered1947",
      "passage": "XXII.14–17, Melchizedek episode",
      "dating_basis": "Palaeography / institutional description",
      "sources": [
        "1Q20"
      ],
      "unresolved": "No new transcription of damaged lines in this continuation"
    },
    {
      "id": "W12",
      "witness": "11Q13 / 11QMelchizedek",
      "composition_estimate": "Second Temple, no later than extant copy",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "First century BCE; narrower published estimates differ",
      "claimed_event_time": "Eschatological jubilee, not a simple Abraham biography",
      "traditional_attribution": "Anonymous interpreter",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Qumran Cave11; discovered in1956 cave finds",
      "passage": "ColumnII, scriptural catena",
      "dating_basis": "Palaeography; precise lab date not verified in this pass",
      "sources": [
        "IAA",
        "11QSCH"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Line restoration and identity interpretation vary; catalogue shell is not diplomatic text"
    },
    {
      "id": "W13",
      "witness": "Philo, Life of Moses",
      "composition_estimate": "First century CE",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Earliest physical copy for these exact loci not verified here",
      "claimed_event_time": "Moses’s childhood and sanctuary",
      "traditional_attribution": "Philo; draws on scriptures and received traditions",
      "language": "Greek",
      "provenance": "Alexandrian Jewish literary setting",
      "passage": "I.20–24; II.124–126",
      "dating_basis": "Author/literary context, not date of narrated event",
      "sources": [
        "PHILO1",
        "PHILO2"
      ],
      "unresolved": "No contemporary Egyptian school register; literary education portrait"
    },
    {
      "id": "W14",
      "witness": "Josephus, Antiquities",
      "composition_estimate": "93/94CE",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Earliest physical copy for selected loci not verified here",
      "claimed_event_time": "Abraham/Moses/high-priestly institution",
      "traditional_attribution": "Josephus",
      "language": "Greek",
      "provenance": "Roman-era Jewish historiography",
      "passage": "I.167–168; III.168,186",
      "dating_basis": "Work’s authorial chronology; selected primary tradition",
      "sources": [
        "EUSEBIUS",
        "JOSEPHUS"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Accounts not contemporary with patriarchs; cosmic explanation not complete tribe table"
    },
    {
      "id": "W15",
      "witness": "Acts, Stephen’s speech",
      "composition_estimate": "Usually later first century CE; proposed dates vary",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Fourth-century Codex Sinaiticus is a complete selected witness; earliest exact-passage fragment not audited",
      "claimed_event_time": "Moses’s Egyptian childhood",
      "traditional_attribution": "Luke–Acts traditional authorship; debated historically",
      "language": "Greek",
      "provenance": "Early Christian literary transmission",
      "passage": "7:21–22",
      "dating_basis": "Manuscript date separate from work and speech date",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE"
      ],
      "unresolved": "No independent Egyptian reading list; Philo/Acts dependency not established"
    },
    {
      "id": "W16",
      "witness": "Genesis Rabbah",
      "composition_estimate": "Late-antique Palestinian compilation, commonly fifth century CE",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Exact43:6 earliest surviving manuscript not audited",
      "claimed_event_time": "Melchizedek teaching Abraham",
      "traditional_attribution": "Named rabbinic views embedded in later compilation",
      "language": "Hebrew/Aramaic",
      "provenance": "Rabbinic literary transmission",
      "passage": "43:6",
      "dating_basis": "Literary/redaction scholarship; printed Hebrew checked",
      "sources": [
        "GR"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Teaching identified as Torah/priestly law, not22/231/32 curriculum"
    },
    {
      "id": "W17",
      "witness": "Babylonian Talmud",
      "composition_estimate": "Late-antique compilation, broadly fifth–sixth centuries CE with later development",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Exact-locus earliest manuscripts not collated; current print checked",
      "claimed_event_time": "Bezalel; rabbinic formation stories; Shem/Abraham",
      "traditional_attribution": "Attributed rabbinic sayings, not narrator autographs",
      "language": "Aramaic/Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Babylonian compilation and later manuscript streams",
      "passage": "Ber55a; San65b/67b; Ned32b",
      "dating_basis": "Layered literary transmission, not event-year equivalence",
      "sources": [
        "BER",
        "SAN",
        "NED"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Book-title variants in Sanhedrin require exact manuscript readings"
    },
    {
      "id": "W18",
      "witness": "Sefer Yetzirah, joined Genizah roll",
      "composition_estimate": "Before tenth-century commentary; exact composition disputed",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "T-S K21.56 +32.5 +12.813, probably tenth century",
      "claimed_event_time": "Cosmogony + Abraham retrospectively",
      "traditional_attribution": "Abraham in closing tradition; author unknown",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Cairo Genizah → Cambridge",
      "passage": "Opening; gate locus; closing",
      "dating_basis": "Palaeography and critical comparison; edition reconstructs damaged text",
      "sources": [
        "CAM",
        "CAMCAT",
        "BA"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Not a patriarchal autograph; use editor’s supplement notation; genealogy disputed"
    },
    {
      "id": "W19",
      "witness": "Saadia commentary",
      "composition_estimate": "931CE",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Later MSS and Genizah material; earliest complete commentary copy not verified here",
      "claimed_event_time": "Abrahamic principles / creation",
      "traditional_attribution": "Saadia is commentator; not the ancient author",
      "language": "Judaeo-Arabic commentary + Hebrew lemmata",
      "provenance": "Geonic milieu; Lambert’s Oxford-based edition",
      "passage": "1:1;2:3;4:4;8:24",
      "dating_basis": "Commentary composition tradition and manuscript comparison",
      "sources": [
        "HAYMAN",
        "LAMBERT"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Eight-chapter arrangement not identical to reconstructed fourfold Genizah structure"
    },
    {
      "id": "W20",
      "witness": "Dunash commentary",
      "composition_estimate": "955/6CE",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Arabic fragments and multiple medieval Hebrew translations; earliest exact excerpt copy not verified",
      "claimed_event_time": "Creation and Abraham/circumcision",
      "traditional_attribution": "Dunash ibn Tamim; teacher Isaac Israeli influences",
      "language": "Judaeo-Arabic → Hebrew translations",
      "provenance": "Kairouan; Genizah and European MSS",
      "passage": "Chapter1 phonetic/number argument",
      "dating_basis": "Authorial dating and translation history",
      "sources": [
        "DUN"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Do not use a translated gate number as automatic reconstruction of Arabic original"
    },
    {
      "id": "W21",
      "witness": "Donnolo, Hakhmoni",
      "composition_estimate": "Tenth century:946 astronomical epoch;982 autobiographical reference",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Genizah witnesses including Oxford Heb.e.26; original image dating not rechecked",
      "claimed_event_time": "Microcosm, creation, sciences; autobiographical material",
      "traditional_attribution": "Shabbetai Donnolo",
      "language": "Hebrew with wider Mediterranean technical vocabulary",
      "provenance": "Southern Italy; later manuscript dispersal",
      "passage": "Genesis1:26 commentary and Yetzirah commentary",
      "dating_basis": "Internal dates/ephemeris and manuscript criticism",
      "sources": [
        "DON",
        "DONTABLE"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Full critical body unavailable in consulted extract; no false claim of complete collation"
    },
    {
      "id": "W22",
      "witness": "Long recension, Vatican299",
      "composition_estimate": "Recension predates selected carrier; origin disputed",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Vat.ebr.299 ff.66a–71b, scholarly dating eleventh century",
      "claimed_event_time": "Creation and Abraham",
      "traditional_attribution": "Anonymous; Abrahamic title/attribution in transmission",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Italian manuscript now Vatican Library",
      "passage": "HaymanA / long recension",
      "dating_basis": "Scholarly codicology, not claimed patriarchal date",
      "sources": [
        "VAT",
        "HAYMAN"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Folio images identified but not independently collated here"
    },
    {
      "id": "W23",
      "witness": "Rashi on Sanhedrin",
      "composition_estimate": "Late eleventh century CE",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Earliest exact-locus copy not audited",
      "claimed_event_time": "Rabbinic creation story",
      "traditional_attribution": "Rashi",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Medieval rabbinic commentary",
      "passage": "65b, ברא גברא",
      "dating_basis": "Author/date and received text",
      "sources": [
        "RASHI"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Explicit interpretation does not identify every earlier formation reference with the extant book"
    },
    {
      "id": "W24",
      "witness": "Bahir",
      "composition_estimate": "Late-twelfth-century Provençal circulation; older materials debated",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "MunichHebr.209,1298, a dated witness reported in critical scholarship; not newly collated",
      "claimed_event_time": "Cosmic principles and biblical exegesis",
      "traditional_attribution": "Pseudepigraphic rabbinic speakers; historical compiler unknown",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Medieval transmission",
      "passage": "§§94–95 in selected numbering",
      "dating_basis": "Dated manuscript tradition vs work’s circulation",
      "sources": [
        "BAHIR"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Section numbering varies; no complete month/tribe table in checked loci"
    },
    {
      "id": "W25",
      "witness": "Ramban Torah commentary",
      "composition_estimate": "Thirteenth century CE",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Earliest exact-locus copy not audited",
      "claimed_event_time": "Biblical camps/blessings interpreted",
      "traditional_attribution": "Moses ben Nahman",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Iberian/Jewish commentary tradition",
      "passage": "Num2:2; Deut33:6",
      "dating_basis": "Textual citation",
      "sources": [
        "RAMNUM",
        "RAMDEUT"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Do not confuse securely authored Torah commentary with other works printed under Ramban’s name"
    },
    {
      "id": "W26",
      "witness": "Short recension, Parma2784.14 / DeRossi1390",
      "composition_estimate": "Recension earlier than carrier; priority disputed",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Selected witness dated1316/17 in published descriptions",
      "claimed_event_time": "Creation/Abraham",
      "traditional_attribution": "Anonymous",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Italian carrier, Parma",
      "passage": "ff.36b–38b, HaymanK",
      "dating_basis": "Catalogue/critical-edition descriptions",
      "sources": [
        "HAYMAN"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Not necessarily the earliest short witness; full apparatus not available"
    },
    {
      "id": "W27",
      "witness": "Gra received version",
      "composition_estimate": "Eighteenth-century editorial/reception context",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Printed Warsaw1884 Hebrew used in this comparison",
      "claimed_event_time": "Ancient creation narrative interpreted",
      "traditional_attribution": "Elijah of Vilna association",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Later edition and reception",
      "passage": "Chapters4–5",
      "dating_basis": "Edition metadata",
      "sources": [
        "GRA"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Not a source for dating the planetary order to Abraham"
    },
    {
      "id": "W28",
      "witness": "Bnei Yissaschar",
      "composition_estimate": "Early nineteenth century; author died1841",
      "earliest_or_selected_copy": "Digital reproduction checked; earliest print not audited",
      "claimed_event_time": "Sacred months and tribal camp interpreted",
      "traditional_attribution": "Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov",
      "language": "Hebrew",
      "provenance": "Hasidic reception",
      "passage": "Nisan1:4; Tammuz/Av1:3; Tishrei1:1",
      "dating_basis": "Named author and textual citations",
      "sources": [
        "BN"
      ],
      "unresolved": "Full camp table below partly derives entries by declared order; no backdating"
    }
  ],
  "recension_collation": [
    {
      "locus": "32 /22 /10",
      "genizah": "Genizah opening p.313:32 paths;10sefirot+22letters",
      "saadyan": "Lambert1:1: same architecture",
      "received": "Warsaw1:1–2: same architecture",
      "consequence": "Numbers stable at these checked loci; not a fixed edge drawing.",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "LAMBERT",
        "SY"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "231 /221",
      "genizah": "Genizah-based D3 p.318:221",
      "saadyan": "Lambert4:4:231; Saadia’s mathematical treatment prefers231",
      "received": "Warsaw2:4:231, at wheel locus",
      "consequence": "Different wording/placement and counting objects; full apparatus still open.",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "LAMBERT",
        "SY",
        "BEN"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Abraham ending",
      "genizah": "Genizah-based D8 p.323: brief ending; Jeremiah1:5",
      "saadyan": "Lambert8:24: Jeremiah plus friend/covenant continuation",
      "received": "Warsaw6:4: Genesis15:6 and explicit22letters on tongue",
      "consequence": "Abraham is shared; particular covenant/revelation language varies.",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "LAMBERT",
        "SY"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Seven planets",
      "genizah": "Genizah D5 p.319: בSaturn גJupiter דMars כSun פVenus רMercury תMoon",
      "saadyan": "Matches the same sequence in checked Saadyan lemmata",
      "received": "Warsaw4:5–11 agrees; Gra4:8–14 differs",
      "consequence": "Read assignments, not merely the list of seven names.",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "SY",
        "GRA",
        "LAMBERT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Twelve simple letters",
      "genizah": "Genizah A6 p.313: הוזחטילנסעצק; D6–7 pp.320–321 details",
      "saadyan": "Lambert1:3; chapter6",
      "received": "Warsaw5 and Gra5 retain month/sign order but faculties/body assignments vary",
      "consequence": "No silent substitution of bodily functions for Babylon’s author definitions.",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "LAMBERT",
        "SY",
        "GRA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Tribal names",
      "genizah": "No complete tribe table in selected letter/month units",
      "saadyan": "None in inspected relevant units",
      "received": "None in checked chapters5",
      "consequence": "Tribe attachment needs independently dated commentary; absence here is not a claim about every manuscript.",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "LAMBERT",
        "SY",
        "GRA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Temple at center",
      "genizah": "Genizah B5 p.314",
      "saadyan": "Lambert2:3",
      "received": "Warsaw4:3; Gra4:4",
      "consequence": "Locates Ramban’s explicit quotation despite modern translator’s inability-to-find note.",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "LAMBERT",
        "SY",
        "GRA",
        "RAMNUM"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Three mothers interpreted",
      "genizah": "Genizah / received text אמש",
      "saadyan": "Saadyan lemmata אמש",
      "received": "Dunash’s chapter1 argument discusses איו for light vowel sounds",
      "consequence": "Text, phonetic interpretation and author dictionary are distinct layers.",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "LAMBERT",
        "DUN"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Organization",
      "genizah": "Bar-Asher reconstructs four thematic chapters from Genizah witnesses",
      "saadyan": "Saadia’s commentary presents eight chapters",
      "received": "Received short/long texts commonly arranged in six chapters",
      "consequence": "Modern section numbers cannot be used as universal manuscript identifiers.",
      "sources": [
        "BA",
        "LAMBERT",
        "HAYMAN"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "verbal_links": [
    {
      "locus": "Ezekiel1:14 → SY1:8",
      "wording": "רצוא ושוב",
      "observation": "The received Yetzirah explicitly introduces the biblical wording with a quotation formula.",
      "direction": "Direct literary dependence on scriptural wording; not evidence that Ezekiel quotes Yetzirah.",
      "limit": "The older Genizah arrangement also uses the phrase in the sefirot material.",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE",
        "SY",
        "LAMBERT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Genesis15:6 → received SY6:4",
      "wording": "והאמין בה׳ ויחשבה לו צדקה",
      "observation": "Distinctive sentence repeated in Abraham ending.",
      "direction": "Clear biblical-language reuse in this version.",
      "limit": "Genizah-based closing instead invokes Jeremiah; no universal ending assumed.",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE",
        "SY",
        "BA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Jeremiah1:5 → Genizah/Saadyan closing",
      "wording": "בטרם אצרך בבטן ידעתיך",
      "observation": "A verse addressed to Jeremiah is applied to Abraham in the book’s ending.",
      "direction": "Shows a concrete act of exegetical reassignment, not biographical verification.",
      "limit": "Jeremiah is not naming Abraham or Sefer Yetzirah in its original context.",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE",
        "BA",
        "LAMBERT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Isaiah57:15 → divine-name opening",
      "wording": "רם ונשא / שוכן עד / קדוש שמו",
      "observation": "Cluster of distinctive divine epithets in the opening.",
      "direction": "Strong shared biblical diction.",
      "limit": "Borrowing a title cluster does not date the entire cosmological scheme.",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE",
        "SY",
        "LAMBERT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Ecclesiastes7:14 → letter/cosmic oppositions",
      "wording": "זה לעומת זה עשה האלהים",
      "observation": "Phrase in the opposition arrangement.",
      "direction": "Explicit textual re-use is stronger than the mere recurrence of12.",
      "limit": "Not an authorial statement about an invariant psychological code.",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE",
        "SY",
        "LAMBERT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Exodus31:3 + Proverbs3:19–20 → Berakhot55a",
      "wording": "חכמה / תבונה / דעת",
      "observation": "The rabbinic passage states its own proof-text combination.",
      "direction": "The inference’s ingredients and direction are visible.",
      "limit": "It attributes knowledge to Bezalel, not a source manuscript to Moses.",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE",
        "BER"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Job26:7 ↔ sefirot belimah",
      "wording": "בלימה",
      "observation": "Unusual term offers a plausible lexical echo.",
      "direction": "A candidate verbal relationship, weaker than an introduced quotation.",
      "limit": "Cannot infer that Job contains ten sefirot or a231gate method.",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE",
        "SY"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Isaiah43:7 ↔ four-world reading",
      "wording": "בראתיו / יצרתיו / עשיתיו",
      "observation": "Three creation verbs give a later reader material for a stage comparison.",
      "direction": "Supports a labelled interpretive comparison.",
      "limit": "Does not name Atziluth or all four worlds; Genesis1:26 says make before1:27 says create, frustrating a simple verb-order proof.",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "locus": "Genesis49 / Exodus24 / Exodus28 ↔ cosmic12",
      "wording": "שנים עשר",
      "observation": "Twelve tribes, pillars and stones are direct biblical statements.",
      "direction": "Establishes actual Israelite twelvefold institutions.",
      "limit": "Common number alone does not establish every letter→tribe assignment.",
      "sources": [
        "BIBLE",
        "PHILO2",
        "JOSEPHUS"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "monthly_correspondences": [
    {
      "letter": "ה",
      "babylon_definition": "Face",
      "month": "Nisan",
      "sign_hebrew": "טלה",
      "warsaw_body": "right hand",
      "gra_body": "right foot",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Judah",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ו",
      "babylon_definition": "Hand",
      "month": "Iyar",
      "sign_hebrew": "שור",
      "warsaw_body": "left hand",
      "gra_body": "right kidney",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Issachar",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ז",
      "babylon_definition": "Word",
      "month": "Sivan",
      "sign_hebrew": "תאומים",
      "warsaw_body": "right foot",
      "gra_body": "left foot",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Zebulun",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ח",
      "babylon_definition": "Root",
      "month": "Tammuz",
      "sign_hebrew": "סרטן",
      "warsaw_body": "left foot",
      "gra_body": "right hand",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Reuben",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ט",
      "babylon_definition": "Joy",
      "month": "Av",
      "sign_hebrew": "אריה",
      "warsaw_body": "right kidney",
      "gra_body": "left kidney",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Simeon",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    },
    {
      "letter": "י",
      "babylon_definition": "Labor",
      "month": "Elul",
      "sign_hebrew": "בתולה",
      "warsaw_body": "left kidney",
      "gra_body": "left hand",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Gad",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ל",
      "babylon_definition": "Mirror",
      "month": "Tishri",
      "sign_hebrew": "מאזנים",
      "warsaw_body": "liver",
      "gra_body": "gall",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Ephraim",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    },
    {
      "letter": "נ",
      "babylon_definition": "Descent",
      "month": "Marcheshvan",
      "sign_hebrew": "עקרב",
      "warsaw_body": "spleen",
      "gra_body": "intestines",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Manasseh",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ס",
      "babylon_definition": "Long road",
      "month": "Kislev",
      "sign_hebrew": "קשת",
      "warsaw_body": "gall",
      "gra_body": "stomach",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Benjamin",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ע",
      "babylon_definition": "Throne",
      "month": "Tevet",
      "sign_hebrew": "גדי",
      "warsaw_body": "omasum",
      "gra_body": "liver",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Dan",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    },
    {
      "letter": "צ",
      "babylon_definition": "Dream / collective",
      "month": "Shevat",
      "sign_hebrew": "דלי",
      "warsaw_body": "stomach",
      "gra_body": "gizzard",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Asher",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ק",
      "babylon_definition": "Hidden",
      "month": "Adar",
      "sign_hebrew": "דגים",
      "warsaw_body": "gizzard",
      "gra_body": "spleen",
      "later_camp_order_tribe": "Naphtali",
      "tribe_status": "Declared camp-order synthesis, not an explicit tribe name in SY chapter5",
      "source": "SY5:2; Gra5:7–10; Numbers2; Bnei Yissaschar Tamuz/Av1:3 and Tishrei1:1"
    }
  ],
  "planetary_comparison": [
    {
      "letter": "ב",
      "babylon": "Saturn",
      "genizah_based": "Saturn",
      "warsaw": "Saturn",
      "gra": "Moon"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ג",
      "babylon": "Jupiter",
      "genizah_based": "Jupiter",
      "warsaw": "Jupiter",
      "gra": "Mars"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ד",
      "babylon": "Mars",
      "genizah_based": "Mars",
      "warsaw": "Mars",
      "gra": "Sun"
    },
    {
      "letter": "כ",
      "babylon": "Sun",
      "genizah_based": "Sun",
      "warsaw": "Sun",
      "gra": "Venus"
    },
    {
      "letter": "פ",
      "babylon": "Venus",
      "genizah_based": "Venus",
      "warsaw": "Venus",
      "gra": "Mercury"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ר",
      "babylon": "Mercury",
      "genizah_based": "Mercury",
      "warsaw": "Mercury",
      "gra": "Saturn"
    },
    {
      "letter": "ת",
      "babylon": "Moon",
      "genizah_based": "Moon",
      "warsaw": "Moon",
      "gra": "Jupiter"
    }
  ],
  "tribe_orders": [
    {
      "source": "Genesis49 blessing sequence",
      "order": "Reuben, Simeon, Levi, Judah, Zebulun, Issachar, Dan, Gad, Asher, Naphtali, Joseph, Benjamin",
      "interpretation": "Not simple birth order: Zebulun precedes Issachar; Gad/Asher precede Naphtali."
    },
    {
      "source": "Genealogical birth sequence from Genesis29–30;35",
      "order": "Reuben, Simeon, Levi, Judah, Dan, Naphtali, Gad, Asher, Issachar, Zebulun, Joseph, Benjamin",
      "interpretation": "Levi and Joseph included; Ephraim/Manasseh not split."
    },
    {
      "source": "Numbers2 camp order, east→south→west→north",
      "order": "Judah, Issachar, Zebulun; Reuben, Simeon, Gad; Ephraim, Manasseh, Benjamin; Dan, Asher, Naphtali",
      "interpretation": "Levi is at center; Joseph represented by two sons."
    },
    {
      "source": "Deuteronomy33 blessing sequence",
      "order": "Reuben, Judah, Levi, Benjamin, Joseph (Ephraim/Manasseh inside blessing), Zebulun/Issachar, Gad, Dan, Naphtali, Asher",
      "interpretation": "Simeon not explicitly named; Ramban discusses the numerical/list problem."
    },
    {
      "source": "Bnei Yissaschar seasonal table",
      "order": "Nisan–Adar in Numbers2 camp order",
      "interpretation": "A dated later interpretive construction, not Genesis birth sequence."
    }
  ],
  "audit_09": {
    "cases": [
      {
        "selection": "A",
        "reference": "Genesis 1:26",
        "written": "נעשה",
        "pointed": "נַֽעֲשֶׂ֥ה",
        "token_id": 637,
        "agent": "God",
        "speech": "present",
        "conception_or_intention": "present",
        "formed_plan": "ambiguous",
        "enactment_of_target": "present",
        "block_or_refusal": "absent",
        "evaluation": "present",
        "text_type": "Creation narrative",
        "expanded_context": "1:26–31",
        "evidence": "Declared intention and image-language; humanity created in1:27; good evaluation in1:31. No separately described inner-conception stage.",
        "what_changes": "Creation follows speech; no named-world sequence.",
        "world_assignment": "Unassigned: no explicit four-world names",
        "four_stage_chain_explicit": false
      },
      {
        "selection": "A",
        "reference": "Genesis 11:4",
        "written": "ונעשה",
        "pointed": "וְנַֽעֲשֶׂה",
        "token_id": 6875,
        "agent": "Builders",
        "speech": "present",
        "conception_or_intention": "present",
        "formed_plan": "present",
        "enactment_of_target": "present",
        "block_or_refusal": "present",
        "evaluation": "absent",
        "text_type": "Collective building proposal",
        "expanded_context": "11:1–9",
        "evidence": "Materials and design in3–4; construction in5; work ceases in8. Desired name/security not certified as achieved.",
        "what_changes": "Partial materialization can coexist with interruption.",
        "world_assignment": "Unassigned: no explicit four-world names",
        "four_stage_chain_explicit": false
      },
      {
        "selection": "A",
        "reference": "Exodus 19:8",
        "written": "נעשה",
        "pointed": "נַעֲשֶׂ֑ה",
        "token_id": 55964,
        "agent": "People responding to Moses",
        "speech": "present",
        "conception_or_intention": "present",
        "formed_plan": "absent",
        "enactment_of_target": "absent",
        "block_or_refusal": "absent",
        "evaluation": "not applicable",
        "text_type": "Covenant promise",
        "expanded_context": "19:3–9",
        "evidence": "A response to covenant instruction. It reports an undertaking, not completion of every promised act.",
        "what_changes": "Promise is not its own fulfillment.",
        "world_assignment": "Unassigned: no explicit four-world names",
        "four_stage_chain_explicit": false
      },
      {
        "selection": "A",
        "reference": "Exodus 24:3",
        "written": "נעשה",
        "pointed": "נַעֲשֶֽׂה",
        "token_id": 59627,
        "agent": "People responding to Moses",
        "speech": "present",
        "conception_or_intention": "present",
        "formed_plan": "absent",
        "enactment_of_target": "absent",
        "block_or_refusal": "absent",
        "evaluation": "not applicable",
        "text_type": "Covenant promise",
        "expanded_context": "24:1–11",
        "evidence": "Moses reports laws. Later ritual acts are narrated, but do not certify completion of all the promised laws.",
        "what_changes": "Keep covenant speech and the particular enacted ritual separate.",
        "world_assignment": "Unassigned: no explicit four-world names",
        "four_stage_chain_explicit": false
      },
      {
        "selection": "A",
        "reference": "Exodus 24:7",
        "written": "נעשה",
        "pointed": "נַעֲשֶׂ֥ה",
        "token_id": 59746,
        "agent": "People hearing covenant book",
        "speech": "present",
        "conception_or_intention": "present",
        "formed_plan": "absent",
        "enactment_of_target": "absent",
        "block_or_refusal": "absent",
        "evaluation": "not applicable",
        "text_type": "Covenant promise after reading",
        "expanded_context": "24:1–11",
        "evidence": "The written/read covenant is explicit; undertaking to do/hear is not a report of future compliance.",
        "what_changes": "Writing, hearing and promising are distinct events.",
        "world_assignment": "Unassigned: no explicit four-world names",
        "four_stage_chain_explicit": false
      },
      {
        "selection": "A",
        "reference": "Leviticus 7:9",
        "written": "נעשה",
        "pointed": "נַעֲשָׂ֥ה",
        "token_id": 78791,
        "agent": "Statutory category; maker unspecified",
        "speech": "not applicable",
        "conception_or_intention": "not applicable",
        "formed_plan": "not applicable",
        "enactment_of_target": "not applicable",
        "block_or_refusal": "not applicable",
        "evaluation": "not applicable",
        "text_type": "Cultic allocation rule",
        "expanded_context": "7:7–14",
        "evidence": "Niphal perfect3ms describes what is prepared in a pan. It is not Qal1cp “we will do.” Rule about entitlement, not an event report.",
        "what_changes": "The same unpointed letters do not fix voice or agency.",
        "world_assignment": "Unassigned: no explicit four-world names",
        "four_stage_chain_explicit": false
      },
      {
        "selection": "A",
        "reference": "Numbers 32:31",
        "written": "נעשה",
        "pointed": "נַעֲשֶֽׂה",
        "token_id": 128166,
        "agent": "Gad and Reuben",
        "speech": "present",
        "conception_or_intention": "present",
        "formed_plan": "present",
        "enactment_of_target": "absent",
        "block_or_refusal": "present",
        "evaluation": "not applicable",
        "text_type": "Conditional military commitment",
        "expanded_context": "32:20–33",
        "evidence": "Terms specify crossing and future fighting. Grant occurs in33; promised crossing not narrated as completed in this context. Sanction is conditional.",
        "what_changes": "Grant, obligation and performed future campaign are different outcomes.",
        "world_assignment": "Unassigned: no explicit four-world names",
        "four_stage_chain_explicit": false
      },
      {
        "selection": "B",
        "reference": "Genesis 37:35",
        "written": "וימאן",
        "pointed": "וַיְמָאֵן֙",
        "token_id": 29728,
        "agent": "Jacob",
        "speech": "present",
        "conception_or_intention": "present",
        "formed_plan": "absent",
        "enactment_of_target": "denied",
        "block_or_refusal": "present",
        "evaluation": "not applicable",
        "text_type": "Refusal of comfort in grief",
        "expanded_context": "37:31–36",
        "evidence": "Family attempts consolation; Jacob refuses and continues mourning. Denied enactment refers only to accepting comfort.",
        "what_changes": "No moral defect or spiritual failure is inferred from grief.",
        "world_assignment": "Unassigned: no explicit four-world names",
        "four_stage_chain_explicit": false
      },
      {
        "selection": "B",
        "reference": "Exodus 4:23",
        "written": "ותמאן",
        "pointed": "וַתְּמָאֵ֖ן",
        "token_id": 43871,
        "agent": "God instructing Moses to address Pharaoh",
        "speech": "present",
        "conception_or_intention": "present",
        "formed_plan": "absent",
        "enactment_of_target": "denied",
        "block_or_refusal": "present",
        "evaluation": "not applicable",
        "text_type": "Refusal quoted in an instructed future speech",
        "expanded_context": "4:21–26",
        "evidence": "At this point Moses is being told what to say. The quoted refusal is not yet a narrated completed encounter in the selected episode.",
        "what_changes": "Temporal embedding matters; quoted futurity is not present observation.",
        "world_assignment": "Unassigned: no explicit four-world names",
        "four_stage_chain_explicit": false
      },
      {
        "selection": "B",
        "reference": "Numbers 20:21",
        "written": "וימאן",
        "pointed": "וַיְמָאֵ֣ן",
        "token_id": 117589,
        "agent": "Edom / Israel as requested traveler",
        "speech": "present",
        "conception_or_intention": "present",
        "formed_plan": "present",
        "enactment_of_target": "denied",
        "block_or_refusal": "present",
        "evaluation": "not applicable",
        "text_type": "Diplomatic refusal with military obstruction",
        "expanded_context": "20:14–22",
        "evidence": "Request and route in17–19; refusal and armed response20; Israel turns away21. Desired passage denied, alternative movement enacted.",
        "what_changes": "Specify whose goal and which action; a refusal itself is an action.",
        "world_assignment": "Unassigned: no explicit four-world names",
        "four_stage_chain_explicit": false
      }
    ],
    "selection_A_tokens": 7,
    "selection_B_tokens": 3,
    "B_absent_books": [
      "Leviticus",
      "Deuteronomy"
    ],
    "outcome": "No case explicitly names/matches four later worlds. Grammar, goals and outcomes must be resolved contextually. Not a causal or blind validation."
  }
}